Open Letter to the EU Commissioner

April, 2020

Open Letter to:

H.E. Ursula von der Leyen
President of the European Commission

H.E. Jens Stoltenberg
Secretary General of NATO

H.E. Josep Borrell Fontelles  

Mircea Geoana Deputy Secretary General of NATO
Commissioner Stella Kyriakides
Commissioner Mariya Gabriel
Mr. Benjamin Hartmann I.D.E.A.

Dear President von der Leyen:
Dear HRVP:
Dear Commissioners:

Request of EC for opinion on COVID-19 /
(Mr. Hartmann, March 16 Letter)

Thank you for asking for our opinion.

There is a large group of respectful leaders today, including those within our own Governments, who are actively contributing to cope with the COVID-19 crisis. To their competent voices we have little to add right now, post factum.

Based on the 30-year experience ofwww.Atlantic-Club.orgin triggering pan-European security policies and implementing innovative solutions (including in cooperation with the EC) we take this call of duty to suggest to the EC some preventive measures to reduce the future risks of repeating this pandemic with another virus or likewise pathogen.

Just as at the time when the world emerged out of the ashes of WWII, we need to exit this current crisis with lessons learned and measures taken. The time to act is now! 

We need to urgently adopt new common EU sanitary and human health protection policy reducing — as much as nature permits — the risk from future repetition of new epidemics. For convenience, we call this future EU policy Health Shield Europe, HeShEu and we suggest that it is implemented in close synergy with NATO. This policy is meant to evolve in the long run as a global one.

Among the various origin sources of epidemics, we herein address a major one:  animal— to—human transmitted viruses and pathogens due to poor dietary, animal farming, hunting and butchering practices around the globe. All of Ebola, Swine flu, Bird flu, HIV/AIDS, SARS and the COVID-19 are caused by such viruses and they originate from continents outside Europe, mainly from zones characterized by poor water and sanitation conditions, including those featuring ―wet markets. These practices are frequently related to illegal wildlife trafficking and flagrant violations of bio diversity.

HeShEu will reinforce the EU’s help to improving, where possible, these conditions — in line with UNHRC Resolution ―The Human Rights to Safe Drinking Water and Sanitation‖ — while at the same time adopting policy to regulate the circulation and exchange of people, goods and businesses with risky zones until the risk is reduced.

After reviewing the global mapping of this sanitary problem, the EU should identify several sanitary zones and — depending on the risk they imply — offer assistance and encouragement proportional to the needs of the country and the capacity of EU, such as know—how, education, good practices and problem-solving oriented Development Aid.

This will be win-win-win for the entire world with a cost much lower than the cost of today’s war with COVID-19, not even mentioning the totality of saved human lives.

Second, further to this,

Dear President von der Leyen:

In parallel with the zone—oriented assistance, HeShEu should provide a real shield to the EU. 
We need to regulate — zone by zone — the physical exchanges and kinetic traffic between the EU and countries in this zone.  The higher the risk of becoming an emergence spot of an epidemic the more precise regulation will be needed.

HeShEu could include a variety of temporary regulatory measures, among which, the following could be included:

  • commuting of people (in both directions) providing sort of medical visas— as e.g. we need yellow fever vaccines to  prevent importing it to some countries, or HIV test was required in the past as risk reducing factor for international trips;
  • outsourcing of businesses and opening new factories and production lines, in or from of risky zones;
  • cross-border exchange of food and other sensitive substances.

Such measures should expire as soon as the respective governments guarantee improving the risky sanitary standards. 

HeShEu should suggest adequate protocols for kinetic exchange of investments, food and risky goods.

In particular, the EU could:

  • strengthen further EU trade policy regulations related to health, sanitary and phytosanitary requirements on imports from third countries and renegotiate EU trade agreements with individual third countries;
  • extend technical and other assistance to developing countries through its development policy to upgrade their capacity to meet the increased high levels of health, sanitary and phytosanitary requirements of the EU;

Regarding foreign investment, it is recommendable to critically review the acquisition of national assets in Member States by foreign actors, which could potentially jeopardize their ability to provide sufficient protection for human health, flora and fauna.  Global supply chains and foreign direct investment policies should operate to the mutual advantage of all peoples and nations.

And vice versa, we need to review EU policies for EU investments in third world countries vis-a-vis human health risks that such investments bear.

In addition to that, a review of Member States' industrial policies is required in order to ensure sufficient levels of production of vital medicines, devices and equipment. The current pandemic has revealed large deficits and a disturbing reliance on imports. Here synergy with NATO is highly recommended.

Further, urgent attention should be given to the possibility of creating an EU Buffer Stock of critical equipment and supplies for EU front line services. We must learn the message from the current crisis and never let supply capacity endanger the lives, welfare and the well being of Europe’s citizens and in particular of front line staff who put their health and their lives on the line in times of crisis.

An added value of such set of regulations will be worldwide saving the lives of many domestic and wild animals, including endangered, rare or endemic species. Moreover, this will boost business exchange via opening space for food companies with higher hygienic standards to share their know-how, in affordable way, on new markets and help people’s health and life at various spots on the globe.

Another European concern: We, the EU, need adequate protocols addressing uniformly the civil emergency situations, both natural and man-made. The free movement of people in the EU and the Schengen Zone make it a must that we adopt uniform quarantine regulations, coordinated by the European Commission, a sort of Medical Schengen Agreement.  

It should include, i.a. common EU regulations vis-à-vis vaccinations and common EU policies preventing the societies from anti-vaccers’ fake news and dangerous practices (the minimum that could be done is to ask them paying the adequate price of their medicare, exactly as speeding drivers pay higher insurances.)

We urge the EC to suggest such uniform protocols for the EU itself while drafting HeShEu.

Once we agree on HeShEu on a EU level, we should offer it to engage sanitary likeminded countries from all over the globe as a basis for agreement on joint global action plan with them.

As a third parallel avenue.  Appreciating the current tendency of NATO’s engagement with the COVID—19 crisis, the EU and its Member States should request that NATO include epidemic threat higher on its security agenda and in this concrete moment invoke Article 5. As we remember, after 9/11 President Bush was receptive to European voices which convinced him for invoking Article 5.

The EU and NATO should develop synchronized protocols for the prevention and reaction to epidemics and other civil emergency scenarios.  Today, the 2015 Bill Gates TED Talk warning for dangers of epidemics as valid now, as it was 5 years ago.  May we turn his wisdom into action plan and do it now!

HeShEu should be developed in cooperation with OECD, WHO, FAO, the Joint FAO/WHO Program on Food Standards, Codex Alimentarius Commission and related stakeholders under the leadership of the Commission and its relevant bodies, in synergy with the European Green Deal as both, a golden standard and long term action plan to implement it globally.  

The EU should suggest to the UN to adapt the initiative as a global one — HeShWorld — and to include it among its Sustainable Development Goals and prioritize the dream of achieving it.

In parallel, we suggest that the EU urge G-7, G-20, FAO, WHO, OSCE and other relevant organizations to strengthen multilateral regulations to echo this process accordingly. To conclude: on the tragic day of 9/11, NATO and the EU were negotiating their ―Big Bang‖ and 5th Enlargements, and some of our countries were on the UN Security Council.

The lesson we learned from 9/11: we need to expect the threats which we do not imagine today. The newest proof of this rule is demonstrated right now by COVID-19, which also shows the devastating and paralyzing effect of the bio weapons. The use of the latter — we must be sure! — have just become the dream of our known and unknown enemies. They observe now that in order to conquer us, they do not need a kinetic attack against us: they could just paralyze us with the next bio weapon. Therefore, before their dreams become true,

Dear President von der Leyen:

As a more general conclusion of the current and similar situations in the past, we suggest that you create a high level Advisory Council on Unimaginable Threats and Emergencies, ACUTE, in the spirit of multiple suggestions and solutions offered by variety of world
NGOs, including of Marc Goodman’swww.futurecrimesbook.comor of thewww.AtlanticClub.orgin the past three decades.  ACUTE should have the imagination of Jules Verne to advise EU on unimaginable but still very real future.

Our team of signatories of this letter is at your disposal for further brainstorming of any of the ideas above and their future implementation.

Sincerely yours,

Dr. Solomon Passy
Founding President (1990–)
Foreign Minister (2001–2005)
Chairman of UN Security Council (2002, 2003)
OSCE Chairman-in-Office (2004)
Bulgaria’s Nominee for NATO Secretary General (2009)

– Signatories –

Alessandro Minuto-Rizzo (Ambassador)
Acting Secretary General of NATO (2003–2004)
Deputy Secretary General of NATO (2001–2007)

Cyril Svoboda
Deputy Prime Minister (2002–2004)
Minister of Foreign Affairs (2002–2006)
Minister of Regional Development (2009)
Minister without Portfolio (2007–2009)
Minister of Interior (1998)
Czech Republic

Dick Roche
Minister for European Affairs (2002–2004, 2007–2011)
Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Local Government (2004–2007) Ireland

Franco Frattini
Vice President EU Commission (2004–2008)
Foreign Minister (2002–2004, 2008–2011) 
Italy’s Nominee for NATO Secretary General (2014)

Gergana Passy 
Bulgarian EU Minister (2007–2009)
Founding President Digital National Alliance

Hans van Baalen
ALDE Party President 
Member EU Parliament (2009–2019)
The Netherlands 

Ioan Mircea Pascu (Prof. Dr.)
Defence Minister (2000–2004)
Vice President EU Parliament (2014–2019)
Member of EU Parliament (2007–2019)

Noëlle Lenoir 
Minister for Europe (2002–2004)
Judge on the French Constitutional Court (1992–2001)

Ognyan Gerdzhikov (Prof. Dr.)
Prime Minister (2017)
Speaker of the Bulgarian Parliament (2001–2005)

Plamen Panayotov (Prof. Dr.)
Deputy Prime Minister for Euro-Atlantic Integration (2003–2005), Bulgaria

Rosen Plevneliev (President)
President of the Republic of Bulgaria (2012–2017)


Dr. Ivan Madzharov
President, on behalf of
Bulgarian Medical Association

Prof. Assen Baltov, MD, PhD
CEO / University Hospital Pirogov 
President / Bulgarian Orthopaedic and Traumatology Association

Prof. Nikolay Gabrovsky, MD, DMedSc
President / Bulgarian Society of Neurosurgery
VP Bulgarian Medical Association

Prof. George Miloshev, PhD
Head / Laboratory of Molecular Genetics, LMG
Institute of Molecular Biology, IMB
Bulgarian Academy of Sciences, BAS

Assoc. Prof. Milena Georgieva, PhD, PI
Academic advisor at ENAGO Academy, USA

Prof. Diana Adlienė PhD
Head of Physics Department
Kaunas University of Technology

Dr. Aliki Mitsakos, M.D., Ph.D.
Founder & Dean
The International Center for Leading Studies

Chang-Hui Shen, Ph.D.
Professor and Chair
Biology Department, College of Staten Island, CUNY
Biochemistry and Biology Ph.D. Program, Graduate Center, CUNY
Institute for Macromolecular Assemblies, CUNY

Dr. Peter Markov, MD, DPhil
Expert in Viral Epidemiology and Emerging Infections


Ambassador Elena Poptodorova
Vice-President Atlantic Treaty Association Brussels
Ambassador of Bulgaria to the USA (2010-2016)

Theodossios Georgiou
President of GAAEC
Administrator and Co-chair for the "Strategic Review" of ATA
President of ATA (1997–2000)

Amb. Ivan Garvalov 
President, on behalf of 
United Nations Association of Bulgaria

Zlatina Todorova 
President, on behalf of 
Erasmus Student Network Bulgaria

Ekaterina Dimitrova
Secretary General Youth ATABG

Ambassador Biserka Benisheva 

Zdravka Evtimova 
President PEN Club Bulgaria


Maxim Behar 
President of World Communications Forum Association, Davos, Switzerland
President (2015–2017) of ICCO, the World’s PR Organisation, official partner of the Council of Europe, London, UK


Direct channel to I.D.E.A. (advisory hub of the European Commission) – Coronavirus
Pandemic Date:
2020-03-16 17:35 From:
Benjamin Hartman